When cash is tight, “pay us in equity” sounds like a perfect answer. You keep your runway, and the agency gets upside. Sometimes it is. Often it’s a decision founders make too quickly.
Why founders consider it
- It protects cash. Early money is precious, and every dollar not spent on marketing extends your runway.
- It aligns incentives. A partner with equity wins when you win, so they have a reason to care about outcomes.
- It buys senior talent. It can put experienced people on your brand before you can afford their usual rates.
When it can make sense
- You’re early, with a strong team and a real market, but little marketing budget.
- The agency is truly committed, with senior people doing the work and not handing it to a junior team.
- The scope is clear and the work genuinely moves the company forward.
- You’d be comfortable with them as a long-term stakeholder.
When to pause
- The scope is vague. If you can’t say what gets delivered and when, don’t pay for it with ownership.
- The ask is large for the work. Equity is cheap to hand over today and can be expensive later, so think about what it could be worth.
- You haven’t talked to your lawyer. Vesting, cliffs and what happens if the relationship ends all matter.
- It complicates your cap table. Investors look at it. Make sure it won’t scare off a future round.
Questions to ask any agency
- Who exactly will work on this, and how much of their time?
- What are the deliverables and the timeline?
- Is the equity vested over time, or all at once?
- What happens if either side wants out?
- Could we combine a smaller equity stake with a reduced retainer?
The middle path
You don’t have to choose between all cash and all equity. A blend of a reduced retainer plus a smaller equity stake can keep your cash healthy while keeping the agency accountable for results.
At Good Dot Dot, we consider equity and reduced-retainer partnerships for the right founders, case by case, in writing and with counsel on both sides.
This article is general business information, not legal or financial advice. Have your own attorney and advisors review any agreement.
